Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

How the American Cryptocurrency Exchange Landscape Has Changed

American Cryptocurrency Exchange: What You Should Know

If you are new to the American cryptocurrency exchange scene, start here. North America is the world's biggest crypto economy by transaction volume, and the rules keep shifting. From Coinbase getting permission for global crypto perps trading to the FTX fallout, there is a lot to track. I am going to walk you through what the data actually shows, what the risks are, and which platforms fit different needs. This is not a corporate briefing - just one person making sense of a messy landscape. The American cryptocurrency exchange space is big, complicated, and moving fast. Here is what you need to know to navigate it.

The Size of the American Crypto Market

North American crypto transaction volume chart
 

An estimated $1.2 trillion in value moved on-chain between July 2022 and June 2023. That represented 24.4% of global transaction activity during that period. Most of the activity came from the United States, which ranked first overall worldwide. Canada also contributed significant volume, ranking seventh globally. North America's crypto market was more driven by institutional activity than any other region. Transfers of $1 million or more accounted for 76.9% of transaction volume. The region's on-chain activity split relatively evenly between decentralized finance, or DeFi, and centralized exchanges. This balance matters because it shows both retail and institutional players have a seat at the table. When institutional money moves, the whole market feels it. When DeFi protocols hiccup, stablecoins often absorb the shock.

Who Drives the Volume

The institutional dominance is striking - three-quarters of volume came from transfers of $1 million or more. This means the market moves on big bets, not just retail frenzy. When a hedge fund or treasury desk moves funds, it ripples through the entire ecosystem. The split between DeFi and centralized exchanges suggests both worlds coexist, but institutional money prefers the controlled environment of centralized platforms for large trades. The on-chain data suggested that North American crypto activity had fallen over the previous year, following negative developments such as the collapse of FTX in November 2022. Activity contracted more in the months immediately following the March banking crisis, when Silicon Valley Bank and crypto-friendly banks Signature and Silvergate closed. The banking crisis was followed by a temporary drop in USDC value in secondary markets.

Activity breakdown
  • DeFi and centralized exchanges each took roughly half of on-chain volume
  • Institutional transfers dominated the overall numbers at 76.9%
  • Retail users stayed consistent through the pullback
  • Sub-institutional pros held steady too

What Happened After FTX Fell

On-chain data suggested North American crypto activity fell after the FTX collapse in November 2022. Activity contracted more after the March banking crisis, when Silicon Valley Bank and crypto-friendly banks Signature and Silvergate closed. The banking crisis was followed by a temporary drop in USDC value in secondary markets. On-chain activity began ticking back up in June 2023. Transaction-size data suggested the pullback from institutional investors was the primary driver of the overall decline. Estimated activity among retail users and sub-institutional professional traders remained relatively consistent. The message here: when institutions retreat, the market contracts, but individual users keep showing up.

"Silicon Valley has always looked for unicorns and disruptors, who by definition don't respect the way that others do things."

The FTX collapse was a wake-up call. Sam Bankman-Fried, the 30-year-old multibillionaire founder, saw his empire crumble. A Hogan Assessments post examined his personality, placing him in a group with Michael Milken, Jeffrey Skilling, and Bernard Madoff. All were described as charming, socially skilled, intense, hardworking, and highly intelligent. All were willing to ignore established rules while taking large financial risks. The post described them as "smart delinquents" - bright, impulsive, edgy, colorful, and indifferent to authority. This is not an isolated pattern. The post connected them to economist Joseph Schumpeter's concept of creative destruction - economic progress depends on challenging norms, defying conventional wisdom, and disrupting standard practices. The post described entrepreneurs as necessary but troublesome and defined them as essential to economic progress.

Stablecoins and the Shift Away from US Control

Stablecoins and international financial institutions
 

Stablecoin activity declined relative to other digital assets beginning around February 2023. Between February and June 2023, stablecoins fell from 70.3% to 48.8% of North America's on-chain transaction volume. The shift away from stablecoins was already underway before the March banking failures. Investor concerns about stablecoins following the banking crisis may have contributed to the shift's continuation. Stablecoin market capitalization fell to its lowest point in more than two years during the summer of 2023. Stablecoins were the most widely used type of cryptocurrency asset in the Chainalysis data. More than half of all on-chain transaction volume to or from centralized services involved stablecoins during the period. More than 90% of stablecoin activity was in dollar-pegged tokens. U.S. regulators had strong interest in exercising authority over stablecoins because of the central role of dollar-denominated reserves. Crypto assets had also been used for crime, including theft by North Korea-linked hackers that ultimately funded North Korea's nuclear program. Limiting stablecoins' role in this activity could have significant effects on crypto-related crime because stablecoins represented such a large share of overall crypto activity.

Stablecoin legislation proposals in Congress
  • The Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act - establishes clear regulatory framework for issuing payment stablecoins, protects consumers, fosters innovation
  • The Responsible Financial Innovation Act - subjects stablecoin issuers to new prudential financial regulations
  • Both aimed to balance consumer protection with market growth
  • Neither passed comprehensive regulation as of the report

"There continue to be important debates around the regulation of stablecoins, such as the appropriate role of state regulators in registering and supervising stablecoin issuers. These debates are resolvable and should be solved soon in the interest of global competition and necessary regulation." - Jason Somensatto, Head of North America Public Policy at Chainalysis

Data suggested more and more stablecoin activity was occurring through entities not licensed in the United States. Since spring 2023, the majority of stablecoin inflows to the 50 largest cryptocurrency services shifted from US-licensed services to non-US-licensed services. As of June, 54.6% of stablecoin inflows to the top 50 services were going to non-US-licensed exchanges. U.S. entities originally helped legitimize and seed the stablecoin market, but more cryptocurrency users pursued stablecoin-related activity through trading platforms and issuers headquartered abroad. The trend reduced the US government's ability to conduct stablecoin oversight and left US consumers with fewer opportunities to use stablecoins under the safeguards of the US regulatory regime.

The Regulatory Push

The U.S. Congress worked on two crypto legislation proposals, and prominent regulators committed to supporting safe growth. The CFTC, which handles CME crypto oversight , signaled intent to bring crypto perpetual futures into the US. CFTC Commissioner Caroline Pham said her organization could pilot a program to support the development of compliant digital asset markets and tokenization. The SEC, IRS, FinCEN, FTC, and OCC all engage in crypto regulation at the federal level. The IRS classified cryptocurrencies as property for tax purposes. The SEC issued guidance on ICOs and token issuers. The CFTC updated guidance on digital asset transactions. Other federal agencies that had engaged in crypto regulation or were considered likely to do so included the Federal Trade Commission and the Office of the Comptroller of Currency. Agencies generally published guidance on their websites, and the Federal Register can be used to monitor regulatory activity.

DeFi's Role in the American Scene

North America historically led the world in DeFi usage by raw transaction volume, but the share of activity attributed to DeFi fell significantly over the previous year. Market turmoil was the most likely explanation - many DeFi protocols focused on trading highly speculative, recently created assets that were not available on centralized exchanges. Those assets were typically the first investors withdrew when markets declined. Regulatory uncertainty surrounding DeFi in the United States was another possible factor. The report described DeFi as having practical applications in trading, asset management, lending, and payments. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong identified borrowing, lending, payments, and staking as additional use cases. He was optimistic about web3 innovations such as decentralized identity frameworks, which allow users rather than large technology companies to own their digital identifiers. The post described a transparency advantage associated with stablecoins and other crypto assets: the inherent transparency of blockchain technology empowers global regulators to investigate and combat illicit activities efficiently.

Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong identified borrowing, lending, payments, and staking as additional DeFi use cases. He was optimistic about web3 innovations such as decentralized identity frameworks, which allow users rather than large technology companies to own their digital identifiers.

Coinbase and Perpetual Futures

The CFTC gave Coinbase permission to offer US customers access to offshore crypto perpetual futures through its subsidiary Deribit, acquired for $2.9 billion. Perpetual futures are derivative contracts with no expiration date. They allow traders to place highly leveraged bets on the future price of crypto assets with borrowed capital. Coinbase was the first US cryptocurrency exchange to receive approval to offer US customers access to the global perpetual-futures market. The CFTC cleared the way for Coinbase to offer all "digital commodity" perpetual-futures contracts traded on Deribit, including markets for Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, Dogecoin, and the TRUMP meme coin. Coinbase would decide which of those assets were fit for purpose and appropriate for US customers. A source familiar with the matter said Coinbase had not yet determined which assets it planned to enable for perpetual-futures trading.

A correct wager on a perpetual future could earn a trader multiple times the initial investment. A losing wager could be liquidated or forcibly closed by the exchange. The report described the resulting liquidation cascade as potentially devastating. The report also referred to rapid crypto-price fluctuations on a single afternoon that wiped out $19 billion in crypto positions within minutes, principally because of the extent of leverage. During the same period, the entire DeFi ecosystem recorded $160 billion in trading volume, while perpetual-futures trading alone exceeded $588 billion. On the Thursday before the decision, Coinbase sent the CFTC a letter requesting a no-action letter. Such a letter would provide assurance that the CFTC would not sue Coinbase if it began offering customers access to offshore perpetual futures. Less than 24 hours later, the CFTC replied with a 16-page document outlining a policy that permitted Coinbase's requested activities. The CFTC also gave prediction-market operator Kalshi permission to create its own Bitcoin perpetual futures in the US. The product would be the first American-born product of its kind. Other exchanges were likely to seek similar access under the guidelines in the CFTC's no-action letter.

The Psychology Behind Exchange Failures

The Hogan Assessments post examined Sam Bankman-Fried's personality after FTX's collapse. The post placed him in a group with Michael Milken, Jeffrey Skilling, and Bernard Madoff. Milken was an American financier with an estimated net worth of about $6 billion, indicted for racketeering and securities fraud and spent time in prison. Jeffrey Skilling was a former McKinsey consultant and the CEO of Enron, the failed energy trading company, indicted for conspiracy, insider trading, and securities fraud and spent time in prison. Bernard Madoff was a financier and former chair of Nasdaq who once had a net worth of $64.8 billion, pleaded guilty to 11 federal felony charges and died in prison. All were described as charming, socially skilled, intense, hardworking, and highly intelligent. All were willing to ignore established rules while taking large financial risks. The post described them as "smart delinquents" - bright, impulsive, edgy, colorful, and indifferent to authority. On dark-side personality characteristics, entrepreneurs appeared creative and inclined to challenge norms, socially skilled but not transparent, and somewhat duplicitous with a delinquent quality.

Entrepreneur personality traits from Hogan data
  • Creative and inclined to challenge norms
  • Socially skilled but not transparent
  • Somewhat duplicitous with a delinquent quality
  • Motivated more by fame, fun, and success than money

The post described entrepreneurs as necessary but troublesome and defined them as essential to economic progress. They could also be described as entrepreneurs who went too far in testing limits in professions where testing limits is expected behavior. The post used socioanalytic theory to explain the behavior of Carnegie and Bankman-Fried. Socioanalytic theory combines Freud's psychoanalytic theory, Mead's role theory, and Darwinian evolutionary theory. It holds that humans have always lived in groups with three universal motives: acceptance, status, and meaning. From this perspective, social behavior is a game in which participants negotiate for status and acceptance. After every interaction, reputations are altered slightly, either positively or negatively. The post also referred to Freud's observation that all public behavior is a text to be interpreted, and to ethologists' view that the essence of animal communication is deception. Based on those ideas, the post drew two conclusions. First, both Carnegie and Bankman-Fried were putting on carefully constructed performances; neither behavior was spontaneous or natural. Second, both were performing for the same audience - their investors - rather than for the general public. If their performances did not match the expectations of their intended audiences, their enterprises could begin to fail.

Where to Track Regulation

The Law Library of Congress compiled resources on crypto and blockchain regulation for international jurisdictions, including Regulation of Cryptocurrency Around the World and Regulatory Approaches to Cryptoassets. The post served as an introductory guide to cryptocurrency regulation and resources in the United States. Because cryptocurrency regulation and legislation were still developing, the post focused more heavily on frequently updated resources while also including law review articles, manuscripts, and treatises. Federal agencies overseeing crypto include the IRS, SEC, CFTC, FTC, FinCEN, and OCC. Agencies generally published guidance on their websites, and the Federal Register can be used to monitor regulatory activity. The Law Library created a guide to federal regulations for research on the subject. The National Conference of State Legislatures provided annotated guides to state crypto legislation and blockchain legislation. Each state legislature's website has different features, but basic search terms can find state legislation in databases. The Law Library of Congress's Guide to Law Online provided links to state legislative websites.

Federal law resources for crypto
  • IRS classified cryptocurrencies as property for tax purposes
  • SEC issued guidance on ICOs and token issuers
  • CFTC updated guidance on digital asset transactions
  • FinCEN and FTC also engaged in crypto regulation

The Law Library of Congress post noted that recent economic and geopolitical events had increased searches and requests for information about cryptocurrency regulation and legislation. The post identified several Congressional Research Service reports, including one on blockchain background and policy issues by Chris Jaikaran, another on CFTC and virtual currencies by Nicole Vanatko, and a third on securities regulation and ICOs by Jay B. Sykes. Stanford University published the Journal of Blockchain Law & Policy, a journal dedicated to blockchain technology and law. Local libraries might have online editions of listed books or access to them through interlibrary loan. WorldCat could also be used to locate the titles.

Practical Notes for Users

When you look for a crypto exchange best fit for your needs, check licensing, fees, and which assets are available. The best crypto exchanges usa users turn to usually offer clear fee structures and solid security. Picking the best us crypto exchange depends on whether you trade frequently or hold long-term. A trading platform cryptocurrency like Coinbase or Kraken gives you options, but always verify the platform's regulatory status. Most crypto exchanges in usa operate under state and federal oversight, but offshore platforms may not. The post noted that neither the authors nor the Law Library of Congress specifically endorsed the following news outlets: CoinTelegraph.com provided frequent updates on cryptocurrency developments, including a page focused on regulation in foreign and domestic jurisdictions. CoinDesk.com was among the first websites to compile cryptocurrency news and linked to policy and regulatory developments.

Quick checks before signing up
  • Is the platform licensed in your state?
  • What are the withdrawal limits and fees?
  • Which assets can you trade there?
  • Does it offer two-factor authentication?
  • If you want to know where to buy any crypto , check if fiat on-ramps are available

Hey, don't skip the security setup part. Enable two-factor auth and move most funds off the exchange. This one's important, pay attention.

Understanding Leverage Risk

Perpetual futures on a 1000x leverage crypto exchange can wipe out positions fast. The report referenced rapid crypto-price fluctuations that wiped out $19 billion in positions within minutes, principally because of leverage extent. The best us crypto exchanges usually cap leverage for retail users, but offshore platforms may not. The best us crypto exchanges share certain traits: clear fee disclosure, regulatory compliance, and responsive support. If you want to know where to buy any crypto with minimal friction, look for platforms with fiat on-ramps and low withdrawal barriers. But always remember - high leverage means high risk, and the house usually wins when users overleveraged. A source familiar with the matter said Coinbase had not yet determined which assets it planned to enable for perpetual-futures trading. The report said the perps market was highly lucrative.

"The inherent transparency of blockchain technology empowers global regulators, including those in the U.S., to investigate and combat illicit activities efficiently." - Jason Somensatto, Chainalysis

Stablecoins were the most widely used crypto asset in the Chainalysis data. More than half of all on-chain transaction volume to or from centralized services involved stablecoins. More than 90% of stablecoin activity was in dollar-pegged tokens. U.S. regulators had strong interest in exercising authority over stablecoins because of the central role of dollar-denominated reserves. Crypto assets had also been used for crime, including theft by North Korea-linked hackers that ultimately funded North Korea's nuclear program. Limiting stablecoins' role in this activity could have significant effects on crypto-related crime because stablecoins represented such a large share of overall crypto activity. Stablecoin regulation could also help ensure that the United States remains home to crypto businesses that may expand the use of the US dollar globally as the digital economy develops.

Stablecoins and International Financial Institutions

A Center for Global Development post examined the risks and opportunities of stablecoins in emerging economies. Stablecoin transactions had risen sharply, and more market participants entered after the passage of the U.S. GENIUS Act. The act created a regulatory framework requiring stablecoins to be backed one-to-one by low-risk assets. Net stablecoin creation increased from $10.8 billion in the second quarter to $45.6 billion in the third quarter, a 324% increase. Total market capitalization was about $300 billion at the time. The source described a major disruption of international payment systems as a matter of time, with potentially profound effects on the global economy. The IMF and World Bank were characterized as the institutions best positioned to help countries realize stablecoin benefits while limiting risks.

Stablecoin risks to watch
  • Not federally insured like bank deposits
  • No central bank acting as lender of last resort
  • Reserves must be fully liquid or confidence can break the peg
  • Can increase competition for bank deposits and accelerate dollarization
  • Susceptible to illicit use across borders and exchanges

The source identified several risks associated with a large increase in stablecoin use. Circle, as a US-based company, was subject to monthly disclosures and third-party audits under the GENIUS Act. Tether was not. Tether had said it planned to issue a US-based version of its currency. If reserves were not fully liquid or managed poorly, confidence in the stablecoin could fall and its peg could break. The source cited the 2023 collapse of USDC's peg as an example - investors rapidly redeemed stablecoins because they were concerned Circle might not access the $3.3 billion in reserves held at the now-defunct Silicon Valley Bank. The IMF and other institutions had warned that rapid stablecoin redemptions could worsen local-currency and financial-market volatility and place pressure on macroeconomic growth. Stablecoins could increase competition for bank deposits, accelerate dollarization, and undermine monetary sovereignty. The risks were greater in volatile markets with high inflation and sharp currency movements. Standard Chartered analysts estimated that stablecoins could draw $1 trillion in deposits from banks in emerging markets over the next three years, including from vulnerable markets such as Pakistan and Egypt.

Growth and Adoption Outlook

Transaction volume and grassroots adoption were down worldwide, but North America still ranked fourth in the 2023 Global Crypto Adoption Index. Regulation was expected to play an important role as the region recovered from crypto winter. The IMF had been active on crypto, advising countries on an ad hoc basis, recommending policy responses, and proposing regulatory requirements. The World Bank was described as largely missing from the discussion, which the post called a gap. The IMF agreed to integrate crypto-asset policies into Article IV assessments and Financial Sector Assessment Programs. The post noted that the most recent FSAP for India did not refer to crypto or stablecoins - a notable omission because India was among the fastest crypto adopters in the world and had not yet adopted an enabling regulatory framework. South Africa's January 2024 Article IV review did not discuss the country's crypto regime, even though the government was positioning South Africa as a potential leader in crypto. The IMF was advised to work with its board to develop explicit criteria for when and how to engage with member countries on stablecoins, including within country programs.

Bottom line for users
  • Check if your exchange is US-licensed or offshore
  • Understand stablecoin risks - not FDIC insured
  • Watch for regulatory changes in your state
  • Keep records for tax reporting - IRS treats crypto as property
  • Diversify beyond one platform

The American cryptocurrency exchange landscape keeps evolving. The CFTC could pilot programs to support compliant digital asset markets and tokenization. Proactive approaches like this promise growth for crypto in North America and other regions. Jason Somensatto described a transparency advantage: "This transparency can also enhance the enforcement of sanctions, allowing participants throughout the crypto ecosystem to screen for and detect activities involving sanctioned entities." The data is clear - the market is big, the risks are real, and the rules are still being written. Your move.

Related Posts

Comments on “How the American Cryptocurrency Exchange Landscape Has Changed”

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Leave a comment

Your comment will be reviewed before it appears on this page.